Recently, I've been pretty jacked up in preparation for the release of Assassin's Creed - a new blockbuster video game from Ubisoft. The game was released on Wednesday, and thanks in large part to the sacrifice of a significant amount of sleep and a very patient girlfriend, I finished up the game Friday night.
Initially, I had intended to writeup a review of the gameplay element of Assassins Creed since I'd never done it before and most reviews I read irritate me =) But after playing the game, I decided I'd go a slightly different route and focus instead on the AC's historical accuracy.
Warning: This post will contain spoilers. So I'd stop reading here if you don't want any of the games plot ruined for you.
For those who haven't experienced the game for yourselves, we'll start with the basics. Assassin's Creed is set during the Third Crusade, more specifically in 1191. The game world is enormous, spanning the middle eastern cities of Jerusalem, Damascus, Acre, and Masyaf, as well as "the kingdom" - the non city environment which connect the major locales. Your play the part of Altair, and in case the game's title doesnt make it obvious, you are an assassin. The story follows Altair as he ends the lives of 9 individuals in the interest of bringing peace to the region . Wholesome family entertainment at its finest ;-)
But as I mentioned, AC's Studio Ubisoft spent quite a lot of time recreating the game world with historical accuracy. Like what? Lets talk turkey.

- Altair is a member of the Hashshashin - an organized group responsible for multiple assassinations during the Crusades period. A little tidbit for you - the word "assassin" comes from Hashshashin.
- Nearly all of the assassin controlled buildings in the game contain one or more small smoking bowls, which I would bet is a somewhat PC way of referring to the ancient tradition of the Hashshashins consuming hashish (a drug) prior to carrying out their missions. The fact that the word Hashshashins looks strikingly similar to the word hashish is not a coincidence.
- Part of the game based creed of the Assassin is never to harm innocents, and your health will actually drop should you let your blade slip against the wrong people. This corresponds with the Hashshashin's vow not to harm the innocent. The real assassin sect did not believe in the use of "less personal" weapons such as poisons, and Altair's disgust is made clear when a character in game does just that.
- The Hashshashin also believed in making a spectacle of their targets to instill a fear of their order - your missions with Altair respect this tradition. No matter who you kill, you always kill them in public with plenty of bystanders and of course, armed guards, nearby.
- As you "partake in altercations" with guards in the various cities of Assassins Creed, you'll hear many different languages yelling at you - English, French, German, and Arabic that I could hear. This diversity in language matches the diversity in the armies of the 3rd Crusade.
- The uniforms of your foes are also historically accurate, from the signature Red Cross of the Knights Templar to the black and white of the Holy Roman Empire, to the red garb and gold lions of King Richard.
- At various spots throughout each of the major cities, you'll come across activists who hold small crowds as they shout various war propaganda specific to whatever side controls said city. I sat on a rooftop edge at one point and listened to to the entire message of one of the Muslim speakers in Damascus. Not only did he curse Richard the Christian King, and praise Saladin (the leader of the Muslim armies) multiple times, but he also got a little more specific. Check out this line:
"I stand before you to deliver a warning! Should Richard take Jaffa, there will be no stopping him! He will march on Jerusalem next. We must end this before it has a chance to begin.". Interestingly enough, following the Battle of Arsuf, Richard did lead the Christian armies to capture Jaffa, though a truce between Richard and Saladin came to pass before an all out assault on Jerusalem. Regardless, this foreshadowing on the part of a random towns person and seeing a crowd gather around him and murmur adds an interesting dynamic to the game, and adds depth to the historical experience.
The Major Players
- Your principle nemesis in Assassins Creed is Robert de Sable, the leader of the Knights Templar. As it were, Robert de Sable was actually a real person, a real crusader, and the real Grand Master of the Knights Templar from 1191-1193.
- Assassins Creed features several appearances by King Richard the Lionhearted. Most know him from Robin Hood fame, but Richard was a very major player in the 3rd Crusade. In July of 1191, the English King lead the Crusader armies to a successful siege of Acre - the exact city where you first see him and the only city you deal with that is under Crusader control. You then encounter Richard again towards the end of the game at the Battle of Arsuf - a real battle in which he lead the Crusader armies to victory over Saladin en route to Jaffa. After this battle, in a conversation between Altair and Richard, there are allusions to peace between Richard and Saladin. Though the game doesn't last long enough to see it, that peace came in the form of a truce and the end of the 3rd Crusade in 1192.
- Speaking of Richard, if you listen to him speak in Assassin's Creed, you'll notice he doesn't sound quite English, but rather has the twinge of a French accent. As first, I had chalked this up to a poor choice in voice actors on Ubisoft's part given that Richard is, after all, the English King. But I decided to do a little homework... and would you believe that I was pwned. As it turns out, King Richard 's mother (Eleanor of Aquitane) was French, and he lived with her native country for quite some time. Essentially, he was raised French. Its a subtle detail but indicative of Ubisoft's attention to the little things.
- One of your early targets is Garnier de Naplouse, who according to the game is a sadistic doctor that has been experimenting on patients within his hospital in Acre. Garnier, like Richard and Robert, was also a real person and was present in the Holy Land during the 3rd Crusade. Whats more, he was a member of the Knights Hospitaller, an order created to supervise hospitals and provide care for Christians who traveled to the region. It appears that the real Garnier was more a military leader than a doctor, as he lead the Knights Hospitaller during the battle of Arsuf. I've been unable to find any record of him having experimented on patients in his care, so his tie to the hospital is a clever dramatization on the part of Ubisoft. The word Hospitaller is used several times during the Garnier mission, a clear reference to his real life origins.
- William de Montferrat is another one of your in game targets that is based on a real person, however there is a less historically accurate tie than some of the other figures mentioned. William was indeed a noble of influence who participated in the Crusades, and he did die in 1191, but, that I've found, he never served in any sort of leadership capacity in Acre.
- In the game, William's son, Conrad, is mentioned several times. He too was a real person, though he never appears in the game beyond references. It is curious that Ubisoft chose to use William rather than Conrad as one of your targets, seeing as Conrad was assassinated by the Hashshashin in real life in 1192.
- One of your later targets in the game is Sibrand. Though it was not disclosed in game, Sibrand was a Grand Master of the Teutonic Knights from 1190-1192. In life he resided in Acre, and Acre is in fact where you kill him. His accent in AC is appropriately German.
- In the game, your home base is the city of Masyaf, which should come as no surprise given that Masyaf is the historical base of the Hashshashin. I'm far from a Crusader scholar, but from the images I've seen, the city appears to have been recreated with a reasonable degree of accuracy on its virtual Syrian mountainside.
- I mentioned earlier that Richard's in game presence in Acre is tied to his real involvement in the siege of the city. Well sieging a city does not occur without a little collateral damage, and the Assassin's Creed version of Acre has just that. As you approach the cities outer gate, small palisade (wooden spike) walls, numerous corpses, and smoking ruins greet you. Within the city, the walls show signs of damage and buildings around the city lie in ruin.
- Acre is a port city which feeds into Haifa Bay and the greater Mediterranean Sea. The digital recreation captures the port beautifully.
- Jerusalem comes complete with several key religious landmarks, including the underground ruins of Soloman's temple, the Dome of the Rock, the al-Aqsa Mosque (I believe), and the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. Soloman's temple and the Church of the Holy Sepulchre are both referenced by name during various missions. According to IGN, the Tower of David is also visible from within Jerusalem, but I havent't confirmed that one myself yet.
- In Damascus, there is a recreation of what I believe to be the Omayyad mosque
- In general, the architectural design of the cities, from the houses, to the markets, to the citadels is impressive, with an eye toward accurately representing the buildings of the time.


Landmarks
In addition to the references Assassin's Creed makes to historical people and events, the cities you play in were also constructed with an eye towards historical accuracy.

More than likely, if you're not a student of the Crusades or a gamer with a curious cat nature, all of this will have been more boring than watching paint dry. But the details are the small (though delicious) potatoes. There is a much bigger picture in all this.
When I talk about the opportunity for video games to support learning, Assassins Creed has provided one of the best examples I've ever seen. Yes it is a game about killing people. No its not historically accurate to the letter. But it is a game that gives you an opportunity to see, and feel, and experience so many of the things that a history class can only give you in words, and to play through some very real historical events during the 3rd Crusade. Its fun. Its incredibly immersive. And it can teach you something (lots of things if you are paying attention) in the process.
I'm not suggesting that Assassins Creed could serve as the primary means of teaching a history class. Thats a bit ridiculous even for me =). But it is the perfect example of a game that could serve as a learning supplement to more traditional mediums - one that can bring educational materials to life in a way that textbooks and lectures can only dream of. It might be a game about death and violence, but Assassins Creed has a huge educational upside with both direct and incidental learning opportunities around every corner. I highly advise checking it out, if even briefly. I'll try and update this post with any additional historical references I can find and maybe even post some screen shots that I didnt pilfer from other gaming sites =)

Images taken from gamespot.com, computerandvideogames.com, pcworld.com, and ign.com and http://users.ociw.edu/mr/photos/syria06/syria06_sepia_album/slides/slideshow_masyaf_castle1.html
Not that this is a research paper, but a lot of my background checks game from "The Crusades" by Hans Eberhard Mayer, notes from my Penn State Hist 108 class, Wikipedia and various referencing sites.







I just did some research on the time period of this game and found one thing that Ubisoft fell trap to because of common myth.
First off, the Hashashins more than likely were not under the influence of hashish or opium as was believed and noted by Marco Polo (the one who is known for christening the legend of the hashish using assassins). The Hashashins were called that by their enemies and persecutors (as well as Crusaders) due to the myth that they were under the influence. Now while it IS debatable and very uncertain whether or not the assassins did actually use these drugs, the Assassins (or Nizari as they called themselves) remained drug-free and were motivated to assassinate their targets by something rather peculiar...wine. It is speculated that Hasan ibn Sabbah was actually a hashish prohibitionist because he believed it to fall under the same category of indulgences as wine according to the Qu'ran. It is believed however that he was a hypocrite and enticed his assassins by giving them wine or rewarding them with it.
Also, the word Assassin is commonly believed to hsve been derived from Hashashin (but more so by foreign and enemy sources), yet contemporary scholars say that the word is derived from "Hassassin" which means "follwoer of Hassan".
Don't take my word for it, but this is what I've researched. I enjoyed your blog!
~S
Nice work and kudos on noticing King Richard's accent, since I didn't. Interestingly, he probably couldn't have spoken English at all because I doubt he even knew it.
Richard was a Norman king who reigned relatively shortly after the Norman king William the conquerer conquered England. Norman is derived from "North men" because they were vikings. They settled in a region of North France now called Normandy. Norman kings of England continued to hold Normandy and other French territories until they were later taken by France. The loss of these territories played a role in causing the Hundred Years' War between France and England.
Norman Kings continued to speak Old French long after capturing England. English is actually a Germanic language with a long history of becoming more like French, the language of government. Even now, words of Germanic origin have a much more casual connotation than those of French origin which have a more formal connotation.
To be fair, though, he isn't actually speaking in the English vernacular from the period, Old English, either. Old English would be pretty much incomprehensible to any modern speaker.
Oh, and yes that is The Umayyad mosque depicted in the game. Like all of the landmarks in the game, though, the scale seems way, way off from pictures I've seen.
Don't forget that Ubisoft made a mistake - The flags used to reprisent the Muslim faction contain the Star and Crescent, a symbol which wasn't used by muslims until the 14th Century, when the ottoman turks adopted it.
I have to thank you for typing this up. It helps me greatly since I'm about midway through the game and was growing ever so curious as to the historical background of it. I bookmarked this for future reference.
I did my research before coming here. This blog helps me even more. It is incredibly immersive as you say. That was one of the things that really caught my eye with the game was seeing the landscape of jerusalem for the first time.
lucy is not missing one of her fingers, though it may seem she is. she simply bends it to demonstrate that she is on his side. the templars would have noticed if she was missing that finger and would kill her
Wow, just wow! I am a huge fan of AC and AC2(seeing as how it is now out)and I had no idea that anything about the game was historically acurate! This really filled me in and it made me pay closer attention to detail in AC2 and I'm noticing a lot of historical aspects that I probably never would have given second thought to before reading this. Thanks for posting this and great work!
and if you care to notice, lucy is missing her right ring finger as well
altair is missing a finger because of the hidden blade, it was both a sacrifice that says that you are very dedicated to the creed, and the hidden blade needs a place to come out. as learned in assassin's creed 2
Umm Hashish is Dried cannabis lol learn your facts buddy it is a drug
what about the history behind assassins creed 2? anyone have any word about that?
Hashish isn't a drug, at least not in an illicit sense, like marijuana or cocaine or whatever. I believe it's legal throughout most of the world. Other than that, nice article, I think history in games is often completely wasted and completely lost on the average player, unless it includes Spartans or killing Nazis.
About Garnier De Nablus (Naplouse):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tj2kC13sgrw&hl=nl
Peace
Ipiki
Garnier de Naplouse also called Werner from Syria.
http://www.templiers.org/garniernaplouse.php
Peace,
Ipiki
You are right about Richard, that's for sure.
Through my nationality, I'm tri lingual & I have done some research. It's going deep, really deep...
In short, it goes from the "Dan" (Den)tribe (Thuata de Danaan) that become "phoenicien" sea warriors & migrate during the Assyrian era,towards Malta, Mediterranean & in the north Scandinavia. Between 850 & the year 1000, these "vikings" invade every European culture, through diverse tribes inter-related & become the new kingdoms, with a nobility that can be traced back through "heraldic history" & genealogy & lives on today.
Some say VIKINGS relates back to the Egyptian "Hyksos" pharaohs, meaning VI KINGS, but that is still mere speculation.
I discovered through diverse sources (through the years) that Rollon is rarely mentioned in history.
Rollon's history goes from Denmark straight to France with 250 ships,makes a deal with Charlemagne.
He becomes Robert le premier, Duc de Normandie ( meaning Lord of the North of France).
His real name is Rognavaldsson Gangerholf, born in Norway,Maer (860-93O, Rouen, France).
He was 2m10 & weighted 150kg, his statue stands in Rouen.
His son is Guillaume , Le longue epeƩ (Wilhelm the long sword) & Duc De Normandie.(900-943)
His son Richard 1 become Duc.(933-996)
Richard 2, son of Richard 1 becomes Duc. (974-1026)
Robert 2, son of Richard 2, better know as the devil/the magnificent. He went to the Crusades & was buried in NiceƩ (1002-1035).
Guillaume Le Batard (the bastard), son of Robert 2,is better known as Wilhelm , the Conqueror, who is also Duc de Normandie, but invades England & becomes King of England(1027-1087).
Henry 1, Beauclerc D'Angleterre ( 1068-1135)son of Guillaume Le Conquerant.
King of England & Duc de Normandie.
Mathilde aka Queen Maud D'Angleterre, daughter of Henry 1 & married with Geoffroy D'Anjou (Lebel & Plantagenets).
Henry 2,D'Anjou, Duc de Normandie, son of Maud.
Becomes King of England after his brother Stephen dies.
His son is Richard The Lion,who fought against Saladin.
Hope you liked it !
There is much more & it's a bit brief...De Medici, The Estes,The Lombardi, Mendez,Nostradamus all seem to have Hebrew roots & from the South, better known as the seraphardes. Those from the North were known as the Ashkenazi (Georgia,Black Sea area. During the Inquisition the Seraphardes fled to Venice, Firenze & later go to Amsterdam where they mix up with Ashkenazi & later found New York.
PS: these are descendant from Rollon: Mitterand, Toulouse- Lautrec,Giscard D'Estaings,Celine Dion, Marquis De Sade & the list goes on & on.
Now,that the presidents are descendants from these tribes & related to the Queen of England, is a public secret. The world is a stage, Shakespeare said.
Shakespeare aka Sir Francis Bacon...
Peace and thanks again for this great article,don't play much games but I like to read & find :)
Ipiki
did you know altair is missing a finger on his right hand ring finger?
Wow, awesome.
I'd studied the Knights Templar for a history project about 2 years before i played AC, and so i was pretty clued up when i played the game, and i have to say, i spent no time at all getting pissed off by the details, as i was pretty much expecting to happen.
The crusades was, politically, a pretty risky choice, especially in the current climate, and one i really think Ubi pulled off with flair, and a great deal of sensitivity to others.
An excellent game, all around.
I recently finished a second play through of the game and was interested to find out more about the history behind it. This post fit the bill perfectly, good work!
altair is missing a fourth finger was this what they had to do like compulsory? im just a kid but this stuff is incredible. i hope to hear more about it soon thanks, jack
No one has the exact information about this creed because the history has been changed from the stronger side at this time and in this time
Just wanted to give you a thumbs up. been looking for this for a while now, was a bit slow to get the game as i was doing so many other thing back then, but got it and finished it and love it. one of the only titles i own across all consoles.
Really like to see a report like this done on ACII in November ( if they dont push the release date back further.
@Chris - Thanks for the support! A large part of what I do professionally is try and encourage the use of games for educational purposes, so to hear that you had your students check out the post is music to my ears.
Unfortunately I haven't had the chance to do similar write ups of other "secretly educational" games - though I do have a list that I'm just starting to get back to. And you can bet that Assassins Creed 2 will get the treatment as soon I can get my hands on a copy. Thanks again!
I am a history teacher and a gamer. I can verify what you wrote is accurate. Some historians disagree on some details, like if the assassins really smoked pot. But over all it all checks out. Great work! I showed it to my students and they loved what they learned. Do you do this with any other game? F.Y.I. AC2 is set in the Renaissance period and is supposed to be more accurate then the first.
The eagle references, the "killing" of altair by al-muhalim are also somewhat historically accurate, the hashish part, not so much. Wiki search hashashin.
This is a fantastic article. I am from Damascus (though currently residing in Providence) and I am greatly interested in the history of the entire region. I agree with you that this game is probably one of the more historically accurate games ever made. If you really enjoy this game, I highly suggest traveling over to these cities with a tour guide and having him show you the landmarks that you can see in the game. I did it while I visited Damascus after the game's release. It was lots of fun and it really conjures up a feeling of satisfaction when you visit the sites because you feel like you've really been there!
very very good work....if you have any other info plz email me!
this was very accurate. the assassins called hassassins is another name for the illuminati who disagreed with religious belief and wanted the population to know the truth
I just wanted to say thank you for this fantastic post! I love historical (if loosely based) fiction. I greatly appreciate the research you put into this as I enjoy the game as well. I'm bookmarking this to read again later. Thank you for doing the work! Very interesting read. I'll send others your way
thanx chris, it was good to know this history behind this game.
i cant find Arsuf????? where do i go?
Thank you so much, I've been interested about the story behind Assassins Creed, and now that I know about it, kudos to you! I'm really interested about the Crusades, and the time period back then.
@Al-Muiz Though I would not dispute the notion that certain claims about Hashshashin have been exaggerated (particularly those that stem from Marco Polo's accounts), I wonder if you clarify your comments a bit. In what way does Assassins Creed represent an erroneous and dangerous interpretation of the beliefs of your ancestors? Though you could speak to this better than I, I found AC to offer a more sympathetic, balanced view than one would typically encounter in the Western historical account of the Hashshashin. Though in all fairness, western history is rather disparaging in that regard, so perhaps even if I am correct, better relativly is still not an appropriate retelling of truth.
The notion of the Assassins is completely incorrect. This was a myth started by the west during the crusades to refer to the Shia Imami Ismaili Muslims in Syria under Hassan-i-Sabbah. This game represents a very dangerous and erroneous interpretation of our beliefs and our ancestors.
None of this should be used for historical accuracy.
Very nice work; it has all the information I was looking for. It's very interesting, noticing all the history that went into this game. Nice to see that someone took care in noticing it :) Congrats, and thanks for putting it together; I love history like this but there weren't any other websites that covered it as well as you did. Great job!
Hey,
I was researching Hashashin for a terrorism project in History,
and being a massive fan of the game, i was pleased when me teacher said i could do a game review of assassins creed's historical accuracy
this is by far the best website i found
thank you for all the help
and i really understand the game more now.
Thank you for all this information!
may i add that there is a really close relation between real Hashshashin leaders Hassan-i Sabbah and Rashid ad-Din Sinan; and Al-Muhalim
Amazing, I always wished to know about the historical facts. I just wish Altair and his ancestors would be treated with more respect.
Um....just a kid who is really interested in certain historical events.Great blog.:)Id like to know more about it.
Hi Chris,
I'm a senior in high school and we have to do an important assignment for school.
My subject is to seek out a game that has some historical background, and look if that background is accurate.
I read your blog and i'm totally stunned.
My question to you is the following:
Can I use things you wrote here in my work ?
and
Do you still have the sources where you got the information that lead to all these conclusions ?
Where did you search all this: books, movies, internet ?
greets Henk
I was impressed with the historical accuracy of the game too but just assumed that was only me lol, also King Richard of england was not only french but hated england infact only spent about 6 months of his entire reign in england i believe and pretty much used the country to fund his wars and also to pay a ransom when he was captured after the 3rd crusade on his way home which nearly bankrupted the country but hey robin hood liked him so he cant have been all bad :P
This was a fantastic game, it brought the history to life. Can't wait for more lke it. Thanks for explaining it all.
hey chris i was wondering if you could give me the full list of assassin targets in the game and maybe some info about them like you did for the 5 you have up.
Thanks,
Jordan
Great post, very well written. I am actually in a historical simulations class at my high school, and our final paper is to pick a historically-accurate game and review it. Thanks a lot for your help, you shall be cited!
Excellent work. I've been looking for a site that actually answers my questions on the historical accuracy of Assassins Creed and you've provided it.
P.s. Assassins Creed also is an compellingly interesting but frustrating game. If you have the patience and take the time to follow the clues in the intervals, where you play as Desmond Miles, and the continuing story after the credits you may find out secrets on Lucy (the assistant) and a way to escape.
Excellent work!
I finished the game and after that, your commentary has turned into a very gratifying piece of work. Congratulations!
I just stumbled across this. The game is made of win, by the way.
One of my majors was Middle East Studies. As far as the city reconstruction goes, about flawless. The accuracy wanes after that. However, as far as a tool to teach critical thinking, this is a game that would be perfect, or at least its cutscenes would be.
Strong work.
Apparently, the Transformers helped the Crusaders conquer the Holy Land for all of Christendom:
http://www.gamebrink.com/blog/2007/11/20/optimus-prime-in-assassins-creed
(use Firefox)
I only read the beginning of your post, just in case there is something in there I didn't know yet. I haven't played it since the night I bought it. I am almost done with Metal Gear Solid 2. Plus, I had to get in some Warhawk. But I'm going to be doing some serious ass kicking with Altair this week.